3 Ingredient Fluffy Yogurt Cake Magic

I’m going to let you in on a little secret, something that has completely changed my dessert game. Forget everything you think you know about baking! This Fluffy Yogurt Cake is pure magic, and honestly, it feels almost impossible that it only uses three ingredients. Seriously, no flour, no butter, no oil—just eggs, yogurt, and condensed milk.

When I first saw the recipe, I thought, “No way that works.” But trust me, the texture it achieves is unbelievable. It’s airy, delicate, and melts in your mouth, kind of like a cloud or that fancy Japanese cheesecake everyone talks about. Because it’s so simple, the technique is everything, and I’ve worked out all the kinks for you.

This Fluffy Yogurt Cake taught me that sometimes the best things in life—and in the kitchen—are the simplest. We’re going to bake this stunner using a water bath, which is the key to keeping it tender and preventing any cracking. Get your eggs ready, because we’re making the lightest cake you’ve ever tried!

Essential Ingredients for Your Fluffy Yogurt Cake

The beauty of this Fluffy Yogurt Cake is its short ingredient list. Three things! But hear me out: you absolutely cannot substitute these items with the low-fat or thin versions. If you do, you’ll end up with a dense, sad little disk instead of a cloud!

We need richness and structure from every component here, since we are skipping all the usual baking staples. Pay close attention to the yogurt—it must be thick Greek style. This is non-negotiable for that signature light texture we are aiming for.

Ingredient Specifications and Preparation

You need four large eggs, and you must separate them perfectly. Any trace of yolk in your whites will stop them from whipping up properly. For the yogurt, grab the whole-milk, plain Greek variety. If your yogurt seems watery, you can strain it overnight in cheesecloth, but getting the thick stuff right off the shelf is easiest. And finally, the sweetened condensed milk brings all the sweetness and moisture we need since there’s no sugar or butter involved.

Equipment Needed for This Fluffy Yogurt Cake

Because this Fluffy Yogurt Cake bakes in a gentle steam bath, you need two pans: one 7-inch round pan for the batter, and a larger dish—like a roasting pan—to hold the hot water around it. You’ll also need a reliable electric mixer for whipping those whites into submission. Don’t skimp on the parchment paper either; you need it lining the pan well past the rim for easy lifting later. It makes moving this delicate cake so much simpler!

Step-by-Step Instructions: Creating the Ultimate Fluffy Yogurt Cake

Alright, this is where the real fun begins. We’re going to treat this batter gently because all that fluffiness is trapped air! Don’t rush this part, and definitely don’t open the oven door early. We’re making a truly spectacular Fluffy Yogurt Cake here, and patience pays off big time.

First things first: preheat your oven to 350°F (177°C). Get your 7-inch round cake pan ready. I grease mine generously and then line it with parchment paper that sticks up a good inch or two above the rim. Trust me, this helps when you pull the cake out later.

Preparing the Batter Base

In a medium bowl, take those four egg yolks and just whisk them lightly. Now, slowly pour in your thick Greek yogurt and the sweetened condensed milk. Whisk this mixture until it is completely, totally smooth. You want zero lumps of yogurt visible. This yolk mixture is the flavor foundation for our whole Fluffy Yogurt Cake.

Achieving Stiff Peaks for the Fluffy Yogurt Cake

This is the most important physical step for getting that incredible lift. Put your egg whites in a very clean, grease-free bowl—I mean spotless! Beat them on high speed until you have stiff, glossy peaks. When you lift the whisk, the peaks should stand straight up and not droop over at all. If they look soft or bendy, keep going! We need that structure for our Fluffy Yogurt Cake to hold its shape.

The Gentle Art of Folding and Water Bath Baking

Now, we have to mix the air into the heavy stuff without knocking it out! Take about one-third of your stiff egg whites and fold them into the yolk/yogurt mixture. This first addition is just to lighten the base so the rest mixes in easier. Then, gently fold in the remaining whites in two batches. Use a spatula and cut down the middle, sweep along the bottom, and fold it over. Stop mixing the second you see no white streaks left. Overmixing here is the death of fluffy cake!

Next, set your cake pan inside a larger baking dish. Carefully pour hot tap water into the outer dish until it reaches about half an inch up the side of your cake pan. This water bath keeps the cake baking evenly and gently. Bake at 350°F for 40 minutes. Then, drop the temperature down to 325°F and bake for 10 more minutes. Don’t peek!

Cooling Secrets for Perfect Fluffy Yogurt Cake Texture

This cooling process is just as crucial as the baking! Once that final 10 minutes is up, turn the oven OFF completely. Leave the Fluffy Yogurt Cake inside the cooling oven for a full hour without opening the door even a crack. This slow cool-down prevents the sudden temperature shock that causes sinking.

After that hour, carefully take it out of the water bath and let it cool to room temperature on a rack. Then, the final step: chill it in the fridge for at least four hours, but honestly, overnight is best. That chilling time sets the texture perfectly for serving.

Tips for Achieving Maximum Fluffiness

If you follow the steps, you’ll have a gorgeous, airy result, but sometimes things just don’t cooperate, right? I’ve learned a few tricks over the years to guarantee that lift in our Fluffy Yogurt Cake. The biggest mistake people make is rushing the egg whites.

Seriously, those whites need to be beaten until they are stiff enough that you could almost hold the bowl upside down over your head—use that visual! If they are even slightly soft, your cake will collapse into a dense layer when you try to fold them in. That’s the number one destroyer of fluffiness.

Another huge tip for the Fluffy Yogurt Cake is to respect the cooling process. That hour in the turned-off oven is non-negotiable. If you pull it out early, the drastic drop in temperature makes the whole thing deflate instantly, like a sad balloon. You’re trapping the hot air in there to slowly usher the cake to room temperature. Also, when you’re folding the whites in, use a big, wide spatula and be patient. It takes longer than you think, but it’s worth the effort to keep all that beautiful air in your batter!

Storage and Reheating Guidelines for Your Yogurt Cake

This light dessert is actually one of the best cakes for making ahead! Because it’s so moist and has that yogurt base, it keeps beautifully. Unlike drier cakes, you don’t really need to reheat this one at all. In fact, it tastes better cold, straight from the fridge!

It doesn’t sit well on the counter for long periods, though, due to the dairy content. You want to keep that delicate structure stable, and the cold temperature helps maintain that perfect melt-in-your-mouth texture we worked so hard to create with this Fluffy Yogurt Cake.

Storing Leftover Fluffy Yogurt Cake

When you have leftovers of your amazing Fluffy Yogurt Cake, cover it loosely. You don’t want to seal it tightly right away, or condensation can make the top sticky. Use plastic wrap that doesn’t quite touch the surface, or just place a lid loosely on your container.

It lasts really well in the refrigerator for up to four days. Don’t even think about freezing it—that texture just doesn’t hold up well after thawing. Here is a quick guide on how long you can keep it safe and delicious:

• Refrigerated (Covered): 3 to 4 days
• Room Temperature: Max 2 hours (due to yogurt content)
• Freezing: Not recommended

Frequently Asked Questions About This Light Dessert

I get so many questions about this recipe because it seems too easy to be true! People always worry about swapping ingredients or what to do if their cake sinks a little. Don’t stress; these little quirks are completely normal when you’re working with such a minimalist recipe. Here are the top things I hear from fellow bakers.

The main thing to remember is that because this Fluffy Yogurt Cake relies on just three items, those items have to do all the heavy lifting! Swapping them out changes the entire structure.

Can I Substitute the Sweetened Condensed Milk in This Fluffy Yogurt Cake?

This is the trickiest substitution, honestly. Sweetened condensed milk does two jobs here: it provides all the sugar, and its thick, syrupy consistency adds essential moisture and body to the batter. If you try to use regular milk and add sugar, you’ll end up with a liquid mess that won’t bake right.

I haven’t found a perfect 1:1 substitute that works without adding flour or butter, which defeats the purpose of this amazing Fluffy Yogurt Cake. If you absolutely must avoid it, you could try making your own condensed milk by slowly simmering regular milk and sugar until it reduces by half, but that adds a lot of extra time. Stick to the can if you want that signature texture!

Why is My Cake Not As Fluffy?

If your Fluffy Yogurt Cake turned out dense or flat, you usually have one of two culprits, and I’ve been there! First, check your egg whites. Did they reach stiff peaks? If they were soft or still looked wet, they collapsed when you folded them in, taking all the potential lightness with them.

Second, check your folding technique. Did you mix too vigorously after adding the whites? You have to be incredibly gentle, using a spatula to slowly incorporate them without squishing the air out. If you see white streaks, stop folding! A few streaks are better than a totally deflated batter. Lastly, did you open the oven door during the first 40 minutes? That sudden cold blast can cause immediate sinking.

Nutritional Estimates for a Slice

Since this Fluffy Yogurt Cake is so simple and avoids heavy ingredients like butter and flour, the nutrition profile is surprisingly light! Keep in mind these numbers are just estimates based on standard ingredient measurements, but they give you a good idea of what you’re enjoying.

Serving Size	Calories	Fat	Carbohydrates	Protein
1 slice	130–150 kcal	6–8 g	15–18 g	6–8 g

If you want to see more of my simple baking experiments, check out my Pinterest board for visual inspiration, or follow along on Medium for detailed write-ups!

Print