Amazing Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Recipe

Listen, if you own a Ninja Creami, you know the drill: you want maximum flavor with minimum guilt. That’s exactly why I developed this recipe for the Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream. Forget those chalky, icy protein desserts you’ve tried before. This one is incredibly rich, smooth, and tastes like you cheated on your macros!

The secret sauce here is using ultra-filtered milk and a touch of pudding mix—it’s my little trick to stop it from freezing rock hard. I spent weeks testing different protein brands to make sure the final texture wasn’t powdery. Trust me, seeing those dark cookie chunks suspended in that creamy vanilla base is pure magic. This recipe is my go-to post-workout fuel, and I’m so excited for you to try it. It proves high-protein treats don’t have to taste like cardboard!

Essential Ingredients for Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

You can’t just throw anything into the Creami and expect perfection, especially when you’re dealing with protein powder. The key to this amazing texture is choosing the right components. We need things that deliver high protein but also help keep the ice cream smooth and creamy, not icy. Don’t skimp here; these measurements are crucial for getting that scoopable texture we’re aiming for.

I keep all these ingredients stocked because making a batch of this Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream is so fast! It’s the 24-hour freeze that takes the longest, not the prep work. Here is exactly what you need to grab before you start mixing:

Ingredient	Amount	Notes
Ultra-Filtered Milk	1 1/2 cups	Use plain or unsweetened if possible.
Vanilla Protein Powder	1 1/2 scoops	Ensure it’s a quality brand your stomach likes!
Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix	2 tablespoons	Do NOT use the cook-and-serve kind!
Chocolate Sandwich Cookies	3 cookies	The classic sandwich kind works best.

Understanding Your Base Ingredients

The ultra-filtered milk is non-negotiable for me. It has less sugar and more protein than regular milk, which helps cut down the iciness and boosts the final protein count for your post-workout treat. Seriously, the difference is noticeable!

For the protein powder, I always go with a good quality vanilla whey or a whey/casein blend. Casein helps thicken things up nicely. If you use a pure isolate, you might need a tiny splash more milk because isolates absorb liquid differently. And that instant pudding mix? It’s the real MVP! It’s a stabilizer that keeps the base from freezing into a brick. Don’t skip it!

The Cookies and Cream Element

When it comes to the cookies, you need that classic chocolate sandwich cookie—you know the one. We only need three, which keeps the sugar reasonable, but they deliver that perfect dark chocolate crunch. Don’t use just plain chocolate wafers; the filling helps add necessary fat and texture.

You’ll want to crush these up quite small before you add them later in the process. I usually put them in a zip-top bag and gently smash them with the bottom of a heavy mug. You want mostly small crumbs with a few slightly larger chunks—nothing too fine, or you won’t get that satisfying *crunch* during the mix-in cycle!

Equipment Needed for Your Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

This recipe is built around one fantastic machine, so you definitely need your Ninja Creami ready to go! If you don’t have the specific pint container, the mix won’t process correctly, so make sure you have that handy. I always keep at least two pints prepped in the freezer just in case I need a second batch ready to go.

You’ll also need a good whisk or a sturdy spoon for the mixing stage. Don’t worry about an electric mixer here—hand stirring works perfectly well. And finally, grab a sturdy zip-top bag and a mug for crushing those cookies later on. That’s it! Simple tools for a sensational treat.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

Okay, now for the fun part! This is where we turn liquid into something truly spectacular. Even though the freezing time is long, your active time here is super quick—maybe five minutes tops. Just follow these steps exactly, especially around the blending and freezing, and you’ll have the best Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream ever.

Mixing the Base and Initial Freeze

First things first, grab your Ninja Creami pint container. We’re going to combine the liquid and the powders right in there. Pour in your 1 1/2 cups of ultra-filtered milk. Then, add the 1 1/2 scoops of vanilla protein powder and those two tablespoons of instant vanilla pudding mix.

This next part is important: you need to whisk this mixture really well, or use a spoon and stir like crazy! You absolutely cannot have any dry clumps of protein powder hiding at the bottom. Keep stirring until everything is completely dissolved and smooth. If it looks lumpy, run it under the faucet and stir some more! Once it looks like smooth, slightly thin milkshake batter, put the lid on tightly.

Place the sealed pint on a completely flat surface in your freezer. I always put mine right in the middle where it won’t get knocked around. Now, you wait. It needs a full 24 hours to freeze solid. I know, it’s tough waiting, but trust me, this solid freeze is what the machine needs to work its magic!

Processing with the Ninja Creami

Once that 24 hours is up—congratulations, you’re halfway there! Take the frozen pint out and remove the lid. Place the pint into the outer bowl of the Creami, secure the lid tightly, and make sure the blade assembly is attached correctly. Pop it into the machine base.

We always start with the Lite Ice Cream function. Press the button and let the machine run its cycle. When it stops, check the texture immediately. If it looks smooth and creamy, you’re good to go! However, if it looks dry, powdery, or crumbly—which happens sometimes, especially with certain protein powders—don’t panic. That’s what the Re-spin cycle is for! Just reattach the lid and run the Re-spin function once.

Incorporating the Mix-In

Once you have a beautiful, smooth base, take the pint out and remove the lid and blade assembly. Scrape down the sides if you see any unmixed spots. Next, take a spoon and dig a small tunnel—about an inch wide and deep—right down the center of the ice cream base. This is where the cookies go!

Take those crushed chocolate sandwich cookies you prepared earlier and pour them right into that tunnel. Don’t dump them everywhere else! Put the pint back into the outer bowl, reattach the lid and blade, and select the Mix-in mode. This cycle gently folds the cookies throughout the base without over-processing the ice cream structure.

When the Mix-in cycle finishes, you can serve it straight away for a perfect soft-serve consistency. If you like it a little firmer, pop it back in the freezer for just 10 minutes before scooping!

Tips for Achieving Expert Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Texture

The Ninja Creami is amazing, but sometimes it needs a little nudge, especially when dealing with protein powder. Don’t get discouraged if your first spin isn’t perfect! Protein bases are notorious for freezing slightly differently than regular custard bases, so a little tweaking is totally normal.

My biggest rule is always to check the texture right after the first run, whether you used Lite Ice Cream or standard Ice Cream mode. If you see anything that looks overly crumbly, dry, or like it has a layer of ice crystals on top, that’s your cue to intervene. That’s why the Re-spin button was invented, honestly!

Also, remember that little tip about serving right away versus freezing? If you want that thick, hard-scoop texture you get from a traditional ice cream maker, you have to give it a little chill time after you mix in those delicious cookies. It makes a huge difference!

Troubleshooting Texture Issues with Re-spin

If your Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream comes out looking powdery or crumbly after the first cycle? That just means the machine didn’t quite process all the frozen liquid uniformly. It happens! Don’t add any more liquid yet—that’s the biggest mistake people make.

Instead, scrape down the sides of the pint container, mixing the dry powder bits back into the main mass. Then, run the Re-spin cycle immediately. This cycle spins it again, but usually at a slightly different speed or duration, which breaks up those ice crystals and incorporates everything smoothly. Most of the time, one Re-spin is all you need to get that beautiful, creamy consistency that tastes just like the real deal.

Storing and Enjoying Your Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

The absolute best way to enjoy this is right after that final Mix-in cycle. It comes out perfectly soft-serve style, and you can eat it immediately! But let’s be real, sometimes you can’t finish the whole pint in one sitting, and that’s fine! If you want a firmer scoop, just pop the lid back on and let it freeze for about 10 minutes before digging in.

If you have leftovers, you need to treat them a little differently than regular ice cream because of the protein content. It will freeze harder than traditional ice cream, so plan ahead for that.

Action	Time/Notes
Immediate Serving	Serve right after Mix-in cycle.
Firm Scoop	Freeze for 10 minutes after mixing in cookies.
Long-Term Storage	Airtight container in freezer for up to 2 weeks.

Storing Leftovers Safely

If you have any leftover Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream, make sure the lid is sealed tightly on the pint. Protein bases tend to develop freezer burn faster than sugar-heavy bases, so airtight is key. When you pull it out later, it will likely be rock solid—that’s normal! You’ll need to let it sit on the counter for about 10 to 15 minutes to soften up enough to scoop. Don’t even think about trying to microwave it; that will just make a soupy mess!

Frequently Asked Questions About Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

I get so many questions about this recipe because everyone wants to nail that perfect texture! It’s easy to customize, but you have to respect the physics of the Creami machine. Here are the things I hear most often about making this fantastic High Protein Dessert.

Can I use a different type of milk for this Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream?

You absolutely can try, but you need to be mindful of the texture. If you swap the ultra-filtered milk for regular skim milk, you’ll lose some protein and creaminess, so you might need an extra Re-spin cycle. Almond milk or water are not your friends here; they are too thin and will result in a very icy, powdery texture because there isn’t enough fat or milk solids to hold the structure.

If you want to go even richer, sometimes I use half ultra-filtered milk and half half-and-half, but be warned—that dramatically increases the fat content! For the best results that keep the protein high, stick close to the original milk suggestion or a high-protein alternative like Fairlife brand milk.

What is the total active prep time for this recipe?

This is where the recipe shines as a quick Post-Workout Treat! The total time listed on the recipe card includes that mandatory 24-hour freeze time. But if you are asking about *active* time—the time you are actually standing there measuring and whisking—it is super fast! We are looking at about 6 minutes of active prep time.

That 6 minutes is spent mixing the base ingredients until they are perfectly smooth and crushing your cookies. After that, you just let the machine and the freezer do all the heavy lifting for you!

Nutritional Estimation for Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

I know many of you are making this because you need a satisfying, high-protein treat that fits your fitness goals, and I totally get that! While exact numbers depend heavily on the specific brand of protein powder you use, I’ve calculated the estimates based on the ingredients listed. This is a fantastic way to get a good amount of protein in without totally blowing your macros.

Remember, these numbers are for one serving, which is usually half the pint. Keep these general guidelines in mind when logging your delicious Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream!

Estimated Nutritional Breakdown Per Serving

Nutrient	Amount (Estimated)
Calories	311
Protein	21g
Fat	8g
Carbohydrates	39g

Sharing Your Success with Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream

I truly hope you love this recipe as much as my whole family does! It’s been a game-changer for my recovery snacks. Did it turn out perfectly smooth on the first try? Did you try a different brand of protein powder? If you want to see more of my favorite recipes, check out my writing on Medium.

Please leave a rating below—it helps other bakers know this recipe is worth the 24-hour wait. Tag me online when you share your scoops of creamy, dreamy Protein Cookies and Cream Ice Cream. Happy spinning! You can also find more visual inspiration on my Pinterest profile.

Print